Skip to main content

mHealth in India- What works and what not?

From remote monitoring to disease management, wireless technology is helping to improve healthcare outcomes and address the healthcare worker shortage. In the U.S., chronic disease treatment costs more than $1.4 trillion each year, but using mHealth could mean a savings of more than $21.1 billion per year.

But in India there is this unique pattern of adoption and push that is to be understood. Over the last decade, telehealth in India has been primarily facilitated and driven by government funding. The government now has a majorpolicy initiative in mobile health. However, in pursuing the broad initiative there is a danger that some of the smaller components can get lost, and this is probably what has happened to telehealth. Many government-driven telemedicine programmes have failed to live a long life. It is no secret that these programmes do not have a successful business model and die after the government grants run out. But if you are a medical device, mhealth app or Disease management software company based out of US or Europe eyeing India as a market-> Follow the money-> i.e. Government contracts.

As a mHealth Consultant, we tried several innovations in the country (already 67+ projects in my kitty) and here is the report card as far as stakeholders are concerned. No wonder, the maximum push is from the Government side but the things that are lacking is a concrete business model? So does that mean there is no for-profit model for mHealth in India.

The answer is YES, there is but we are still gearing up. I have met several companies from Switzerland, Israel, US and Europe and the whole reason for them to enter the Indian market was cashing on consumerism and scale. Remember, things may not turn out in your favour for the first 3 years if you are working on a for-profit model in India, so you have to be patient and try and work with the right partners and channels. However, quick money is always something that Government tenders provide.

As far as services are concerned Remote monitoring in India has not taken up as yet. Below given is a infograph on some of these services and their adoption in the country. Also refer to our survey report on Diabetes monitoring.

At this point in time, more than 4 large states in India are looking to set up a Non-emergency help line for consumers and people who live in rural areas and do not have access to basic health. Tele-triage companies from US and Europe have already submitted their interest for the same. Similarly, mobile clinics, telemedicine centres and health information on mobile phones is catching up as priorities amongst Indian Government. We all know about Dr SMS - an initiative of Kerala Government. (Healthcursor Consulting Group has prepared a report on several such reforms that were implemented by Govt. of India from the year 2005 onwards and lessons learnt - available for a price on the website).

There appear to be a number of steps required if telehealth in India is to keep up the pace of development, as we move into what is now being called the era of m-health, involving visual media, skype and hub and spoke based remote health service delivery. This area is changing extremely rapidly and is increasingly migrating away from the public sector in India, where most of the developmental work has occurred, and into the private sector. Some of the factors that lack in Govt. based implementations here are:

1. Patient satisfaction – do patients like the technology?

2. Clinical efficacy – how well we can treat the patients remotely rather than face to face?
3. Business case and sustainability – development of clear metrics to measure the project, including for example decreasing number of transports, reduced rate of hospitalisation and increased productivity. Many of the issues require consideration within the domain of m-health in India are also relevant to other countries. M-health will significantly change the way that health-care is practised in future, and it is clear that it is the human factors that are more difficult to overcome, rather than the technological ones.

Popular posts from this blog

AI and Deep learning for Cervical Cancer

Worldwide, the cancer of the cervix (lower portion of the uterus) is the fourth most common cancer. It is also one of the most common causes of deaths due to cancer in women.

Most of my patients that participated in my public health project had wither dementia, Alzheimer's or were frail and sometimes immobile. They would forget their surroundings, spouse name and even getting a regular medical checkup was a challenge. These women, when asked to go for cervical cancer diagnosis, opted out and never showed up. Most of these tests are widely available but are uncomfortable and invasive. Patients are also not keen to go for them unless indicated.

1 in 5 cancer patients across the world experience delay in diagnosis and, it holds true for cervical cancer as well. Cervical cancer is diagnosed more frequently at more advanced stages.

The human papillomavirus (HPV) infection is responsible for 90 percent cases. However, all women infected with this virus will not develop cervical cancer. …

Royal Society of Medicine elected Dr Ruchi Dass Fellow

Popular Health Technology Author and Founder, HealthCursor Consulting Group Dr. Ruchi V Dass elected Royal Society of Medicine Honorary Fellow in the United Kingdom. (Photo courtesy of Ruchi Dass)

Joining some of the elite names among scientists and physicians, Health Technology Author and Business Icon Ruchi Dass has been elected as a fellow of The Royal Society of Medicine in the United Kingdom.

Dass is a renowned Physician and has worked with development organisation across the world driving technology driven public health initiatives. She is the Founder of the consulting group HealthCursor, and Author of several journals, including her upcoming book on “Big Data in Healthcare” with Springer.

Dr Dass wrote a book on “Innovations in Healthcare” that was unveiled by the Honourable President of India Mr. Pranab Mukherjee in 2013. Dr. Ruchi Dass was listed amongst Most Powerful and Influential leaders in IT by Information week in 2013 and also received INTEROP’s “Women leader” recogni…

The Formula of Driver and Demand- Indian Startups story

The healthcare industry is currently experiencing change at an unprecedented rate. Change is not only occurring in the technology used in diagnostics and care delivery, but this change is so fundamental that it could, and likely will, fundamentally alter the business model of the industry.
Today we have fitness bands, healthcare apps, appointment schedulers, health chats and several such means to access healthcare but one thing that all of this does not necessarily correlate with high quality of care or better outcomes. We need to understand that “Not even a Ferrari will get us to our destination without a driver.”Formula of Driver:
Driver = (Need + Incentive) where;
Incentive = (Value + Reward) Need = (Gap + Demand)
To define the best drivers, we need to first address the need. Need might not make economic or business sense but it is the best opportunity to leave an impact. No one remembers how much business a “Mughal-e-Azam” or “Usual suspects” did but everyone remembers that these were…